Indiana's Bootlegging Resurgence: Cigarette Taxes and the Modern Day Smuggler

Indiana's recent cigarette tax hike is more than just a fiscal strategy; it echoes the state's bootlegging past. As legislators increase the per-pack cost, they are also introducing strict penalties for smugglers, reminiscent of Prohibition-era moonshine raids.

The parallels to the 1930s are striking, with historical documents recounting mid-1900s shutdowns of illicit liquor and tobacco networks. The focus today has shifted to interstate routes and malls, where savvy smokers look for deals in neighboring states.

Border states like Kentucky with its low cigarette tax of 10 cents per pack become natural hubs for smuggling, while Tennessee experienced a similar rise in illegal cigarette trade after its tax increases in the 2000s.

A report by Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health highlights that despite potential smuggling, revenue post-tax hike increased 43% after Indiana raised prices from 55¢ to 99.5¢ per pack in 2007.

Crackdown Ahead: Enforcing the New Law

Starting July 1, Indiana more than doubles its cigarette tax, implementing rigorous enforcement measures:

  • Out-of-State Purchases: Making bulk purchases a felony offense.

  • Task Force Enhancements: State and Excise police will scrutinize shipments at strategic points like toll booths.

  • Surprise Wholesaler Audits: Targeting fraudulent tax stamps to combat contraband.

  • Anticipated annual revenue: $290 million, benefiting public health initiatives.

Cross-Border Challenges

Enforcement challenges persist due to Indiana's vicinity to low-tax states. A Tax Foundation report predicts a potential smuggling rise, citing "border hopping" risks.

Ohio also poses a threat with its highway network and relatively low taxes. A Mackinac Center study suggests 12% of Indiana's cigarette consumption could arise from out-of-state buying in the post-hike aftermath.

Playbooks from Illinois & New York

Illinois:

  • Raised nicotine taxes to 45% of wholesale, resulting in significant smuggling concerns.

  • Significant portion of cigarettes likely smuggled, prompting stricter punishments for unstamped packages.

New York:

The Hoosier Bootlegging Legacy

Bootlegging runs deep in Indiana's history. During Prohibition, southern counties thrived off moonshine trade known as "Whiskey Roads." Now, it's all about tactical tax evasion—packs replacing pints.

A Health Policy or Economic Bet?

A surge in smuggling is not seen as a total policy failure by some health experts. Higher prices encourage reduced use, notably among youth and low-income groups.

As The Indiana Capital Chronicle reports, higher cost is a proven deterrent, with potential for reduced youth smoking rates.

Strategic Question: Will It Work?

Indiana's bold move hangs on more than projections. The actual outcomes depend on enforcement effectiveness, retailer compliance, and potential smuggler tactics.

Only time will determine the success of this initiative. For now, old-school smuggling savvy lives on in modern forms along Indiana's routes. While stakes are higher and logistics differ, the heart of the matter remains unchanged.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Jeanie K's Tax and Accounting We'd Love To Chat!
Please feel free to use our Ai chat assistant or click the contact button below.
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully