Michigan's Marijuana Tax Dispute: Implications for the U.S.

Michigan is once again a focal point in the evolving landscape of cannabis legislation, currently embroiled in a significant legal battle concerning a 24% wholesale tax on marijuana. As the legal contest unfolds, stakeholders across the nation are watching closely, considering its potential implications on not only cannabis pricing but also on broader tax policies and voter-approved laws.

Even if your daily life involves neither cannabis consumption nor residency in Michigan, the significance of this legal challenge cannot be overstated. It holds the potential to influence how other states design, amend, and uphold cannabis tax laws, offering a glimpse into future legal skirmishes as the cannabis sector continues to expand.

Image 1

Understanding Michigan's Proposal

As an integral part of Michigan's 2025–2026 fiscal budget, authorities have sanctioned a 24% wholesale tax on cannabis. This levy is designed primarily to fund road repairs, and it impacts the supply chain before products hit retail shelves.

Already, Michigan enforces two additional taxes:

  • A 10% excise tax on cannabis retail transactions, implemented with the legalization decision in 2018

  • The statewide 6% sales tax. Should this new wholesale levy take effect, Michigan would feature one of the most substantial cannabis tax frameworks in the U.S.

Industry's Legal Challenge

The Michigan Cannabis Industry Association (MCIA) asserts the new tax is unconstitutional, arguing it contravenes the 2018 voter-mandated cannabis law by lacking a necessary supermajority legislative vote.

Given the protections enshrined in the Michigan Regulation and Taxation of Marihuana Act (MRTMA), any amendments demand a three-fourths supermajority. This wholesale tax, however, was hurriedly approved with a simple majority vote.

MCIA’s spokesperson, Rose Tantraphol, emphasized to the Michigan Advance: “Protecting the integrity of voter decisions is paramount.”

Industry representatives also caution that this tax could push operational costs higher, pressure small businesses, and potentially drive customers back to unregulated markets—a pattern previously observed in states with high tax rates like California.

State's Defense

From Michigan's perspective, the tax maintains legality by:

  • Constituting a new levy, separate from the 2018-approved cannabis statutes.

  • Exercising legislative authority to meet fiscal requirements.

  • Focusing on securing funds for road infrastructure without modifying cannabis policy.

If courts concur with the state, the tax might become effective on January 1, 2026.

Possible Consumer Impact

Americans must note how tax structures affect economies, as outcomes often transcend state lines. If this tax withstands scrutiny, anticipated consequences include:

  • Escalating wholesale prices

  • Potential hikes in retail pricing to align with costs

  • Some consumers possibly opting for illicit, non-taxed markets

  • Increased pressure on smaller market participants, possibly leading to consolidation

Image 2

Conversely, if invalidated, Michigan would maintain its reputation for low-cost cannabis, advantageous for continued competitiveness.

National Relevance

Though a Michigan-specific issue, the repercussions of this lawsuit extend beyond its borders.

1. Examining voter law limits

If legislative amendments can occur sans supermajority, the fundamentals of voter-driven initiatives could face reevaluation nationwide.

2. Influencing other states' cannabis tax designs

States grappling with similar fiscal challenges may observe this tax's journey, pondering comparable structures.

3. Emphasizing tax variability

From modest tax regimes in Oregon to California's higher tiers fueling black markets, states could recalibrate based on Michigan’s outcome.

Future Trajectory

The Michigan Court of Claims has commenced hearings, with a decision forthcoming, potentially reaching the Michigan Supreme Court.

Whatever the decision, it promises to resonate widely, impacting not just Michigan's cannabis entrepreneurs but also setting precedents for handling voter-led laws, nascent markets, and tax competencies nationwide.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Jeanie K's Tax and Accounting We'd Love To Chat!
Please feel free to use our Ai chat assistant or click the contact button below.
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully